This a traditional letter column.
You are encouraged to write a letter of comment on anything that you
find worthy of comment. It will (may) be published in this column along
with my reply. As editor I reserve the right to delete material;
however I will not alter the undeleted material. E-mail to me that solely
references the contents of this site will be assumed to be publishable
mail. All other e-mail is assumed to be private. And, of course, anything
marked not for publication is not for publication. Oh yes, letters of
appreciation for the scholarly resources provided by this site will be
handled very discreetly. This page contains the correspondence for
October 2001.
From: “Mike C” ([email protected])
Hello, my name is Mike and I am a big fan of the short story by Tom Godwin, “The Cold Equations”. After searching on the internet about anything pertaining to “The Cold Equations”, I have come across your articles written on this subject. Your article was very good, right now I’m trying to think of every way to get to a copy of this story. I’ve tried to look for it everywhere, through internet search engines, tried to see if Sci Fi would play the movie on tv, and even tried to look for and buy it off of ebay and tried to download anything about it off of Morpheus.
Well I just wanted to ask you if you know of any way I can get a copy of this story, I really want to reread this, it’s probably my favorite story of all time, followed closely by J. R. R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings. I have read “The Cold Equations” about 7 years ago, and I has been on the back of my mind since then, but I haven’t been successful in locating this at all.
Please let me know if you have any ideas for me in my search for the story, thank
From: “Maria Kirby” ([email protected])
Just had to tell you that this is absolutely the funniest story I have ever read or heard by anyone (including comics, comedians, comediennes, etc.). Bravo!
It came at a time when I needed a good laugh too!
From: Bob & Barb Baker ([email protected])
fascinating site.forwarded by an e=mail by a friend.
I just wanted to thank you for the wonderful page you have and am sorry i did not send thanks sooner. Over at least the past year I have enjoyed it greatly and look forward to the updates, thank you for what you provide here- take care
From: “David Erickson” ([email protected])
Christ you write a lot. You must type fast. I got a job at the
University of Minnesota Genetics and Metabolism department as an admin
assistant, started dabbling in online database publishing to try and make
the job more interesting, started writing a book called “The Soul Gene”.
Imagine my lack of suprise that someone had the same idea. In my concept,
it’s an induced mutation that leads to a sort of enlightenment, expect
that the narrator and a few others can’t sustain the transformation. Sort
of a combo satire, social commentary thing. If you have no objection, I
would like to continue with the title, but if you strenuously object, no
problem. I’m flattering myself that it will someday be Vonnegut/Walker
Percy-ish, since I don’t have a style of my own. I wrote some other tome
that failed to publish, along with about 300 pop tunes that failed to
chart, so I find creativity is re-directing towards being a tool of mental
survival rather than a means to get cash. The burnout from trying to
appease idiots out of their money is too much to take. Nevertheless I
will try to sell the thing.
Here’s a website of “creative” shit that I haven’t updated forever:
www.twistednoodle.com
Here’s a business I’m trying to sort out with a friend of mine:
www.pricefile.com
Anyway, nice to encounter some intelligent life out there. I read “Atlas
Shrugged”. Then I shrugged.
Of course you can use the title “The Soul Gene”. It turns out that titles
can’t be copyrighted which is a good thing – quite a few titles are reused.
In any case I have no objection.
Came across your site in a random search…. been having fun poking around. Great stuff.
Thought you’d like to know of a link that needs updating on page http://www.tiac.net/users/cri/dinosaur.html referred to Russ’s Dino Lair.
The lair is still there but needs updating.
Thanks allot!
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: (no subject)
hi i was wondering if i could have your imput for a report im doing on old science fiction that is now reality. thanks for ur time
Space travel is the big one. It isn’t too far off the mark to say that the
US space effort was strongly influenced by science fiction.
Murray Leinster wrote a story called “A logic named Joe” which foresaw
the internet.
Nuclear power and atomic weapons and the issues surrounding them
were written about well before they were a reality. Example stories:
“Solution unsatisfactory” and “Blowups happen” by Robert Heinlein.
There was a lot of science fiction about robots. For the most part
these were about artificial humans; however “The door into summer”
has a pretty good version of industrial robots.
From: “Kandi Harter” ([email protected])
SO, you must know my Dad, right? All this sound familiar. Some kind of
childhood memories. Maybe nightmares. I am not sure.
Kandi Harter
You can not really read this stuff after a few beers.
From: JC
You’re funny!
How did you get to be so smart?
Was it God or were you just called that way?
“Never try to out smart a girl.
Please consider adding a link from your site to my service “The Alfred Russel
Wallace Page,” at:
http://www.wku.edu/~smithch/index1.htm
Wallace is one of history’s most prominent naturalists and creative thinkers,
and I have over 150 of his writings on various matters up online in
full-text. There is also much other information on Wallace available at this
much-praised site, including extensive bibliographies and indexes.
Thanks very much for your time and attention!
–Charles H. Smith, Ph.D., Associate Professor, Western Kentucky University,
Bowling Green
From: smcgrew ([email protected])
your jane austin site is roaringly funny.
From: “Sarah Peck” ([email protected])
Hi, my name is Sarah and I’m looking for the man that filled weather
balloons with helium attatched to a lawn chair. I don’t think he died…
but still got an award. Do you know where I could find his story, or even
what the story was?
From: “Torrey, Arthur” ([email protected])
I just found your paper on A Game Theoretic Approach to the Toilet Seat
Problem on http://members.ozemail.com.au/~tarim/men/toiletsp.htm, which I
was pointed at by the ‘Ifeminists’ list put out by Freemarket.net.
I greatly enjoyed your paper, and think it is a worthwhile contribution to
the literature on the subject.
In your remarks section you assert (Remark #1)
In the event that Task #2 is being performed, the manipulation cost is
constant regardless of gender. However the same can not be implied in the
event of Task #1! The cost to Marsha for performing #1 in the lid closed
scenario is merely a lid manipulation. However John must perform both a lid
manipulation AND a seat manipulation. While these two manipulations can be
combined in most scenarios, the weight manipulation requirement, and the
possibility of encountering objectionable residue from prior task
performances is greater in John’s case.
Thus I feel that your assertion in Remark #6
I would suggest that in any future revisions of your otherwise excellent
paper, you include an appropriate discussion of this difference in costs for
the lid down solution.
Your point is well taken. I shall draw attention to this difference in costs
when I next revise the paper, an event that shall surely occur before the
onset of the next millennium.
From: “Moyra Rowney” ([email protected])
I’m looking for a poem taught many years ago at school……
The last line is:
Ozzimandis, King of Kings
Another line is:
I met a stranger from a foreign land
OR
I met a traveler from a foreign land
Your assistance would be greatly appreciated.
I met a traveler from an antique land
This web page contains the sentence “Class Acreodi excludes Cetacea”. I
presume “class” is in error for “clade”, as used elsewhere on the page.
Hey, I’m Thinking About Becoming A Marine. I Came Acrosss Your Web Site
When Searching Around For Information On It. I Would Like To Ask You What
Kind Of Stuff You Went Through In Boot Camp, I’m Guessing Its Nothing Like
The Tv Show, At Least I’m Hoping Its Not, That Looked Kinda Easy, So
Please If You Have Time Send Some Information, Thanks
Cheerily,
From: “Stephen Struska” ([email protected])
Sir:
I fail to see the different stages of the eye in the fossil record.
Bloody interesting site – I stumbled across it whilst trying to find sommat
on “Waiting for Godot” – interesting piece – is it your doing?
Anyway, after taking that in I grabbed a scotch, well Tang, and went for a
roam around your corner of the universe – too much for one sitting but I
intend to return. Liked the review for Mr T Pratchett – given the evident
humor on the site have your ever read any of Spike Milligan’s war memoirs?
You should.
My site is indeed large. This is not an accident. It is intended to be
too large, too diverse, and too warped to be assimilated by any sane mind.
Comments on the sort of mind that could create such a thing will be
ignored.
I have heard of Spike Milligan but I haven’t read anything by him. I have,
however, read “Nice Girls Finish Last”, which I can recommend.
From: “Dick T.” ([email protected])
Dear Mr. Harter,
The enclosed file contains a Press Release letter to you about my book.
If you should decide to read it, I know you will enjoy it.
I enjoy your web site. Thanks for being there.
Richard Tiernan
Note: Richard Tiernan’s book, BONES, is published by iUniverse.com, $15.95
(ISBN: 0-595-19925-9).
Sometimes what they intend to put on the PA isn’t all that reserved
either. I was on board for all of these:
– (Northwest) after a flight delayed 3 hours (missed its slot, then
needed to persuade off enough passengers to make a lower takeoff
weight since the air was warmer): “Ladies and gentlemen, you can’t
imagine how glad we are to finally welcome you to Boston’s Logan
International Airport.
– (Frontier (I understand they have a rep)) during taxi-out: “In case
you haven’t been in an automobile since 1962, insert the metal tongue
into the buckle….”
– (Qantas) after a bad landing at Fiji: “It’s not for nothing we have
a kangaroo on our tail!
Some one of these days I will have to write up my personal “airline trip
from hell”, a seven hour flight from Minneapolis to Chicago.
From: “Paul J. Gans” ([email protected])
I’ve read your page on Richard’s Scripting Langauge. What you have
is interesting, but I think it is missing one major point. In what
way will RSL differ from perl, python, bash, etc., etc.?
That is a good question and I’m not sure that I have a good answer.
There is, of course, that ancient urge of programmers, “I want to do
it my way,” an urge that has produced any number of horrors. This
may be one of them.
An equivalent answer is that perl, python, bash, etc., are so boring.
They all seem to be variants on unixy line-noise trash.
Let me get back to you on this one. Incidentally this is the first of a
series of articles. The second, arithmetic, is the subject of interesting
and sometimes hot discussion on comp.lang.misc.
Of course you could always fall back to the old WordStar key
bindings….
Index of contributors
Mike C
Maria Kirby
Bob & Barb Baker
Mike Huber
David Erickson
Loren Schultz
Oshi1114
Kandi Harter
JC
Charles Smith
smcgrew
Sarah Peck
Arthur Torrey
Moyra Rowney
Stewart Robert Hinsley
FoOFiGhTeRs1575
Stephen Struska
brian m asquith
Richard Tiernan
Charles Hitchcock
Paul J. Gans
Other Correspondence Pages
Archived Letters For 1996
Archived Letters For 1997
Master page for correspondence
January 2001 Letters
February 2001 Letters
March 2001 Letters
April 2001 Letters
May 2001 Letters
June 2001 Letters
July 2001 Letters
August 2001 Letters
September 2001 Letters
Date: 10/21/2001
Subj: The Cold Equations
Ouch.. I don’t have any really good suggestions. I have a copy of the August,
1954 issue ASF which is where the story originally appeared. That issue and
other SF magazines are available from specialty dealers. As my essay notes
it is reprinted in The Ascent Of Wonder: The Evolution Of Hard SF (TOR 1994).
It is also reprinted in The Science Fiction Hall of Fame, vol I if I recall correctly.
I imagine both books are out of print although the The SF Hall of Fame is
reprinted every so often. Your local used book stores might have one or the
other. If not there are resources on the web for finding used books.
Return to index of contributors
Date: 10/20/2001
Subj: Review (he he he he he he he) of (he he he he he he) … (he he he he he he he he) Ryan’s (he he he he he) … (crying now) (he he he he he he) Family Steakhouse (he he he he he he he … he he he he he) ROTFLMAO!!!!
I must admit that I didn’t compose that little gem – “Bob” passed on to me
with the proviso that his name not be mentioned. It would make a great
comedy sketch but I don’t think TV is quite ready for it
Return to index of contributors
Date: 10/12/2001
Subj: send me e-mail
Thank you. There is much wisdom to be found within my pages.
I don’t know where it is exactly but I am sure that it must be in
there somewhere.
Return to index of contributors
From: “Mike Huber” ([email protected])
Date: 9/17/2001
Subj: my thanks
You’re welcome. It’s always nice to know that people appreciate my little
efforts to enlighten the world, particularly considering how little they are.
Return to index of contributors
Date: 10/18/2001
Subj: convergence
Do I write a lot? Not compared to some. The chap who wrote most of
contents for “The Shadow” pulp magazine wrote upwards of a million
words a year. Isaac Asimov wrote several hundred books including some
he shouldn’t have.
Return to index of contributors
From: “Loren Schultz” ([email protected])
Date: 9/24/2001
Subj: broken link
Loren, (an ex-prairie dweller in the middle of the metro)
Thanks for the heads up. I’ve corrected the link. I’m glad you liked the
site. The neat thing is that it turns up in a lot of random searches.
That’s the up side. The down side is that it turns up in a lot of random
searches.
Return to index of contributors
From: Oshi1114 ([email protected])
Date: 10/9/2001
Subj: Old science fiction
This is probably a bit late for your report but it is an interesting question.
Return to index of contributors
Date: 10/17/2001
Subj: Harters
Do I know your dad? Probably not, although we might have corresponded
if he is one of the Harters listed on my web page of Harters.
… continued on next rock …
That’s the best reason for having a few beers that I’ve heard so far.
Return to index of contributors
Date: 9/17/2001
Subj: Hey there good buddy!
My parents were very poor and they couldn’t afford
stupid pills for us kids.
I’ve been reading Kirkegaard. That guy was real
horny.
That’s the usual explanation.
One time, I got up and read a poem wrote that started
Ignore Neal Young.
Don’t say Don’t…”
I don’t think you’re going to get rich writing poetry. Then again,
nobody gets rich writing poetry.
Now that entire bar thinks that I’m one of the 24
Elders of the New Jerusalem.
Have you ever considered that maybe they’re right. You should check
into it. Maybe they have a good pension plan.
Return to index of contributors
From: “Charles Smith” ([email protected])
Date: 10/16/2001
Subj: suggested link
Thanks for the suggestion. I’ve added the link.
Return to index of contributors
Date: 10/3/2001
Subj: Jane Austin
Thank you. I had hoped that it would be.
Return to index of contributors
Date: 9/26/2001
Subj: looking for a specific story
See http://www.tiac.net/users/cri/darwin97a.html
Return to index of contributors
Date: 9/26/2001
Subj: Possible peer review criticism on your Toilet Seat paper
Note: The above link is a copy of a usenet posting of the paper. The
official version is at
http://tiac.net.users/cri/toilet.html.
However I see an objection to one aspect of your discussion in the paper,
as it pertains to manipulation costs when the toilet seat lid is involved.
“The toilet has an additional attachment called the toilet seat lid which
can only be down if the toilet seat is down. When the lid is down the
toilet is (or should be) non-functional for toilet operations. Some
persons maintain the toilet seat lid in the down position when the toilet
is not use. For these persons the analysis in this note is moot. Such
persons pay a fixed cost in seat movement for all toilet operations.”
While certainly true as to regards the requirement for a manipulation prior
to each use, this cost is NOT a constant, as it is dependent on which task
is being performed, and which gender is performing the task.
“The toilet lid solution is to put the toilet lid down after all toilet
operations. This solution imposes a cost of 2C on each party and is
accordingly more expensive. It is, however, more esthetic. It also
eliminates the “doggy drinking” problem”
Is demonstrably false. In fact the cost factor of a lid manipulation is
not C but L. While Marsha’s cost per operation is 2L, as is John’s in the
case of task #2, John’s cost for task #1 is not 2C but rather 2(C+L) (Note
that as implied earlier, the cost (C+L) is greater than cost C or cost L
alone, but not necessarily equal to the sum of costs C & L performed as
separate manipulations)
Dear Sir,
Return to index of contributors
Date: 10/4/2001
Subj: Help Please
You are thinking of “Ozymadias of Egypt” by Percy Bysshe Shelley.
The entire poem (a sonnet) is as follows:
Return to index of contributors
From: Stewart Robert Hinsley ([email protected])
Who said: Two vast and trunkless legs of stone
Stand in the desert. Near them, on the sand,
Half sunk, a shattered visage lies, whose frown
And wrinkled lip and sneer of cold command
Tell that its sculptor well those passions read
Which yet survive, stamped on these lifeless things
The hand that mocked them and the heart that fed;
And on the pedestal these words appear:
“My name is Ozymandias, king of kings:
Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair!”
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Date: 9/30/2001
Subj: http://www.tiac.net/users/cri/acker06.html
I will check with James Acker but I fancy that “class” is correct. The
reference is to the usage in the traditional taxonomic hierarchy, e.g., class,
order, genus, species, et cetera.
Return to index of contributors
From: FoOFiGhTeRs1575 ([email protected])
Date: 10/2/2001
Subj: Hey
Boot camp is easy. They shave your head, you get at least four hours
sleep a night (most nights), the drill instructors shout at you a lot, you
get a lot of good exercise, you learn how to spit shine shoes, and your life
isn’t cluttered up with irrelevancies like movies, radio, reading books,
drinking, eating candy, or a social life outside of your platoon. You eat
gourmet food created by mess hall cooks who lost their taste buds in
the last war. It helps to have a good set of lungs so that you can shout
“YES SIR” loud enough to drown out the sound of low flying jets. Don’t
worry about not being in shape; they will get you into shape in a hurry
– the hard way. Boot camp is a piece of cake, metaphorically speaking.
That’s metaphorically speaking because you can forget about cake and
other soft goodies while you are in boot camp. Oh yes, your drill instructor
will kindly explain to you in great detail your many deficiencies and the
great distance between recruits and real marines. He will do this
frequently because you might forget from time to time what with being
run ragged and he will do it loudly in case your hearing isn’t too good.
Return to index of contributors
Richard Harter
USMC 1517593
Date: 9/26/2001
Subj: Sure!?!?!
Your failure to see bespeaks an unfortunate stage of eye.
If all of you evolutionists would realize that Creation explains
everything that Evolution still is trying to explain. The Creation Theory
is by far more complete and has not changed since it happened. Nothing
occurs in nature that cannot be explained by the Creation Model.
To be sure, everything can be explained by creation models as long as
one does not go beyond “Everything is the way it is because it was created
that way.” There are minor difficulties, e.g., there are quite a variety of
creation models and theories, the details are notably missing, and they
aren’t particularly consistent with the world around us.
Return to index of contributors
From: brian m asquith ([email protected])
Date: 10/12/2001
Subj: ?
The “Waiting for Godot” piece is indeed mine. For some reason that page
is quite popular, probably because it turns up early on some of the search
engines. No doubt I am doing irreparable harm to the serious scholarly
study of “Waiting for Godot”. I certainly hope so. There is a maxim that
in life one should plant a tree, sire a son, and do irreparable harm to a
field of academic study. I have planted no trees and sired no sons; I must
make do with irreparable harm.
Return to index of contributors
Date: 10/10/2001
Subj: My new book has a reference to your web site
Last April I wrote to you asking permission to use information from your web site relative to Piltdown Man for my new book, Bones. You kindly gave me permission. My book is now available and your web site is mentioned in my Bibliography. The reference information about Piltdown Man is written into the story line on pages 175-176.
Thanks for the update. I don’t know whether I will get a chance to read
your book – my reading list is very long – but I am confident that it is quite
good.
Return to index of contributors
From: Charles Hitchcock ([email protected])
Date: 9/19/2001
Subj: an encounter with Hurricane Bob
Oh my.
Return to index of contributors
Date: 9/19/2001
Subj: RSL
It will be much, much nicer. 🙂
As far as editors go (you asked for comments), I’ve found that
the vi-emacs controversy is religious and you will never satisfy
folks in the other camp. I’m a full vi man. Emacs is the work
of the devil. Obviously others have them the other way around.
So my advice is do what you think best.
Teco. Real programmers edit in Teco. Hell, real programmers program
in teco.
Return to index of contributors
This page was last updated October 22, 2001.